NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPEpic Wear Liquid Liner, Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner - Black

Still the best eyeliner I've ever used. Lasts SO long, I put some on around 8am and throughout work, a hot yoga class, and a shower afterward, it's still clearly visible on my eyes. The only drawback is that it's a thick formula, and when you're putting it on, it can get on your eyelashes, making applying mascara difficult. But I use eyeliner only, no mascara, or I apply this after mascara, and it's the best.

this is my favorite eyeliner! definitely waterproof, just new buyers beware, makeup remover doesn’t take this baby off (unless it’s oil based)! I use coconut oil to take it off haha. really good eyeliner!!!

This silver liquid eyeliner is VERY pigmented and. Metallic looking. I wanted something to match my chrome silver nails and this will definitely work. FYI this liquid eyeliner is definitely waterproof as well, it doesn’t budge

This eyeliners strength is also its weakness; it does not come off easily. I’ve included pictures of just after I did my makeup and after I washed my face and used a Qtip and micellar water to scrub the middle away. I gave up after that and just left it on overnight and it looked virtually the same in the morning. My next guess is to use coconut oil to get it off but we shall see!

This is the longest lasting, most durable black liquid eyeliner I've found. Please never stop making this! Stays on forever, not sticky, not flakey. It does take a while to dry.

I put this eyeliner on this morning. I cried 5 times, applied sunscreen and played soccer for 2 hours, even took 2 showers and it has not BUDGED. Exactly what I have been looking for!

I have hooded eyelids and have tried a lot of different waterproof/smudge-proof eyeliners... I had high expectations for this product but it didn't quite deliver.Liquid liners usually exhibit one of three behaviors after a full day:1) Cracks and flakes2) Get waxy and smudges3) Get rubbery and peel off in big chunksIn terms of longevity I didn't find it to be more durable than some of the cheaper liners I've tried, but the worst part is this liner falls into category 1: it cracks and flakes, which is my least favorite behavior since it gets into the eyes and iritates.

Great product for heavy eyelids. Does not smudge when you apply light power over top.